Menu
0

800-523-2319experts@tasanet.com

Articles

Injuries in Rear Crashes, Seat Structure and Product Liability Issues

TASA ID: 3190

Questions of adequate seatback strength, or the lack thereof, have been raised in many product liability claims against automobile manufacturers over the years. What role do the structures of the automobile seat and seatback have in injuries to vehicle occupants? What is the current state of knowledge?

Here are some facts based on my structural and statistical analyses, as well as the relevant published research.

Product Liability Issues

The Claims:  In the product liability arena, the claims generally have involved the lack of adequate strength in the seatback structure, with allegations of this having led to large excursions of the occupant, resulting in injury-producing contacts with parts of the vehicle or with rear occupant. Claims have also been made that stronger structure for seatbacks would likely reduce or eliminate these injuries. 

The product liability debate has focused on 'stiff' seatbacks versus 'yielding' seatbacks and the advantages of each. It should be noted that seatbacks are 'distributed structures' and thus cannot be scientifically described by a single parameter or by one simple term ('stiff', 'yielding' etc.) These non-technical descriptions of a complex structure are used to convey the notion that one seat ('stiff') would have undergone smaller deformation under a controlled laboratory test than another (yielding') seat in exactly the same test.

 The Statistics

Big Picture: The average number of occupants involved in crashes every year in the U.S., as estimated from the NASS-CDS database of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, is shown here (Ref 1).  

Comparison of this 'exposure' data with the recorded injuries in the above database for the years 1996-2007 shows that rear impacts are associated with comparatively lower rates of injuries than other crash modes. The observed number of injuries where the recorded maximum AIS (which stands for 'Abbreviated Injury Severity') was two or greater is shown here and illustrates that the ratio 'number of occupants with maximum AIS of 2 or greater' to 'number of rear crashes' is the smallest of the categories shown here. Similar conclusions (Ref 2) are drawn when injury rates are examined for the category of passenger cars struck in the rear by light truck vehicles (which include SUVs, small pickups and vans). In this category, rear crashes account for 29% of all cases but only 8% of the total 'societal harm.'

Who is Involved in Rear Crashes?  The estimated annual number (from NASS-CDS data) of automobile occupants involved in rear crashes for the year 2007 shows the age distribution to be fairly widespread across the driving age population.  

Risk Ratio versus Age: The cross-relationship between the number of occupants involved in the crashes versus the number of those with 'K' or 'A' injuries was examined and is shown here for the year 2007 as a percentage. The peaks in the

 

plot are due to the small number of cases available. The injury risk is observed to be fairly uniform across the age spectrum but with higher risk for older drivers.

Past Research

Simple relationships between the DV (change in velocity of the vehicle) and injury parameters have been proposed to explain the complex phenomena of injury causation in rear crashes. For example, one paper (SAE paper 2003-01-2205) concluded that 'stiff' seatbacks provide equal or better protection than 'yielding' seatbacks and defined 'serious injury zone' and 'no serious injury zone' based on the  mass of the occupant.

A subsequent publication (SAE paper 2007-01-0708) presented data contradicting the validity of the above findings. Other papers have analyzed the effect of variables such as seatback recline angle (SAE paper 2009-01-1200).

The Structural Mechanics Of Seats

Do Seatbacks Fail? : All structures deform (i.e. yield under loading). Seatback deformations may consist of several components:

- Compression of the padding on the seatback  

- Bending and deformation of the seatback frame

- Rotation of the seatback around the hinges

- Deformation of recliner structure and resulting rotation of seatback

- Motion and deformation of the seat bottom structure

- Deformation of the vehicle floor and resulting motion of seat and seatback

- Deformations in the joints and connections

- etc.

Structural Design: The design practice is to provide adequate structure in the seat and the seatback to support the expected operational loads, while meeting other constraints of aesthetic, comfort and performance criteria.  Designs are also dependent on features, e.g. recliner mechanisms, electric motors, attachment points of seatbelts, etc. A photograph of a modern seatback structure is shown here.

 

Design for Crash Safety: In a rear crash, the loading on a seatback consists principally of the occupant's mass multiplied by the vehicle's forward acceleration. In other crash modes (e.g. frontal and oblique crashes), seatbelt forces also need to be considered, since they may be a significant part of the loading on the seat and the seatback. 

The loading pattern in a purely rear impact will be a rearward loading on the seatback, as well as a bending moment at the base of the seatback. The resultant force on the occupant may be visualized as one force component tending to slide the occupant upward and rearward along the seat, and the second component causing compression of the seat with resultant rearward displacement of the occupant. The total excursion of the occupant is the vector sum of all the components.

From this simplified analytical model, observations may be made as follows:

- Injuries to the occupant may result from contacts with various parts of the vehicle including the seatback, headrest, roof, pillars, rear seats, etc. (This assumes that the occupant remains contained within the vehicle).

- The magnitude of injury is dependent on the structural property of the contacted component, the rate of acceleration (or deceleration) of the body segment, and its injury tolerance threshold.

- The larger the seatback recline angle, the larger the force tending to slide the occupant (upward and rearward) out of the seat, and the smaller the force causing seat compression.

- The dynamic friction between the seatback and the occupant is the principal component resisting the sliding motion. The contact area between the occupant and the seat/ seatback is one of the factors influencing the dynamic friction.

- For a properly positioned occupant, a 'softer' seatback structure may lead to a larger contact area because the resulting compression of the seatback causes more of the occupant's torso to be in contact.

- For a properly positioned occupant, a 'softer' seatback structure may lead to smaller (as compared to the case below) 'sliding excursion' and larger (as compared to the case below) 'compression excursion.'

- Conversely, for a properly positioned occupant, a 'stiffer' seatback structure will likely lead to larger (as compared to the case above) 'sliding excursion' and smaller (as compared to the case above) 'compression excursion.'

- For occupants that are 'out of position' (such as leaning sideways and/or in a fully- reclined seat, etc.), the resulting motion in a rear crash may not utilize significant portion of the seat structure properties and the available dynamic friction.

In order to apply the above general observations to specific incidents and to reliably evaluate the likely causes of injuries, it is necessary to examine the event and the vehicle structure in detail, establish the forces on the occupant, and then evaluate the contributions of the seatback structure, as well as of any other vehicle components.

                                                  

Results from this finite element simulation confirm the conclusions from the earlier simplified structural analysis. For the case where the seatback and the supporting structure have been stiffened to eliminate structural displacement and deformation, the 'seat compression excursion' is eliminated, but a large amount of 'sliding excursion' of the occupant may result and lead to multiple possible contacts between the occupant and the vehicle's interior, such as  torso-to-seatback, head-to-roof, neck-to-headrest and head-to-headrest.

                              

A study of the kinematics of a 95th percentile ATD (Anthromorphic Test Device) in a rigid seat in the same vehicle was also conducted, and the results are shown here. It is observed that for this case of a rear crash, the contacts between the occupant's body segments and the interior parts of the automobile occur at different instances of time and involve a different set of kinematics. Although not presented here, the impact velocities of the body segments and the vehicle interior were also different in this case than that for the 50th percentile ATD.

                                

Other Factors in Design of Front Seatback

Safety of Rear Seat Occupants in Frontal Crash: Since the design of an automobile should comprehend likely operating conditions and crash scenarios, the role of the seatback structure of the front seat should also be evaluated for the case when a rear seat occupant is present and the vehicle is involved in a frontal crash. In this case, the rear occupant's impact will be with the back of the front seat. Simulation of a mid-sized sedan in a 30 mph frontal crash was conducted with a 50th percentile male ATD  in the rear seat, restrained by a three-point seatbelt with pyrotechnic pretensioners. The front seat and some other parts of the vehicle are shown as planes in order to visualize the contacts clearly. The front seat position was approximately the position that a driver (of the size of the 50th percentile male ATD) would have set.

CONCLUSIONS

The interactions between a vehicle occupant and the structures of the seat and the seatback depend on several inter-related factors, such as direction and severity of crash, resulting vehicle deformation and dynamics, occupant sizes and postures, seat position and recline, structural geometry and dynamic properties, etc. In examining crash performance of a vehicle's seat and seatback during a crash, it is necessary to evaluate all these factors and assess the effect of any proposed design changes across the spectrum of operating conditions and the crash scenario.   

REFERENCES:

1. "Evaluation of Pre-Crash Sensing and Restraint Systems Effectiveness," SAE Paper 2010-01-1042

2. "Perspectives On Vehicle Crash Compatibility and Relationship to Other Safety Criteria," Enhanced Safety Vehicles Conference, Paper 2003- 412

 

This article discusses issues of general interest and does not give any specific legal or business advice pertaining to any specific circumstances.  Before acting upon any of its information, you should obtain appropriate advice from a lawyer or other qualified professional.

This article may not be duplicated, altered, distributed, saved, incorporated into another document or website, or otherwise modified without the permission of TASA.

Previous Passenger Platform Level of Service
Next Auto Manufacturer’s Liability in Pedestrian Injury Cases-Effect of Automobile’s Front Structure Design
Print
Tasa ID3190

Name:
Email:
Subject:
Message:
x

Let Us Find Your Expert 

Note: This form is to be completed by legal and insurance professionals ONLY. If you are a party in a case that requires an expert witness, please have your attorney contact TASA at 800-523-2319.

Submit

Search Experts

TASA provides a variety of quality, independent experts who meet your case criteria. Search our extensive list of experts now.

Search Experts

Testimonials

  • I think it's always good to have access to experts when [TASA] make[s] the process so easy."

    Scott McIntosh, Lewis McIntosh & Teare, Royersford, PA

  • As a busy practitioner, managing a sizeable caseload, I can use all of the help available to me. If I can outsource a task, particularly one as important as securing a qualified expert, I will jump at the opportunity. I use TASA in nearly every case where I need to find an expert witness, be it an engineer, an architect, an economist, etc. They have thousands of qualified experts to refer in virtually any field. Best of all the process is extremely simple. When I need an expert I simply contact TASA, whose knowledgeable representatives ask you targeted questions about your case, your legal theories, and your goals, in order to find the right expert for your case. I usually receive CVs and calls from the potential expert within hours. If you find the originally selected person is not a good fit – for whatever reason – TASA will work with you to find the right person. I would happily recommend this service to any attorney."

    Patrick K. Gibson, Gibson & Perkins PC, Media, PA

  • Ms. Darlie I. McDonald RN was awesome on the witness stand, and we prevailed in our case to the tune of  [a] (highly unusual [amount] for a medical malpractice [case] in our area).  I'd highly recommend her."

    Shane Reed, Shane A. Reed Law Office, Jacksonville, OR

  • I appreciate your inquiries and offers of assistance as well as the consistently high-quality, well-organized, and erudite TASA webinars, which invariably have excellent presenters."

    Maurice S. Kane, Cummings McClorey Davis Acho and Associates PC, Riverside, CA

  • Steven Kursh was an outstanding technical expert on our ecommerce IP lawsuit. He completed a massive amount of work on extremely complicated material, in a very short period of time. His work product was first rate and I think he would have done a terrific job if the case proceeded to trial. He is very articulate and helped us. I only wish we had gotten him involved sooner in the litigation."

    Daniel J. Brown, Reiss Sheppe LLP, New York, NY

  • I thank you all for the response to my request for an expert witness...Both Mr. Scott and Mr. Bianchi appear to be well-qualified for this case, but we have hired another expert. As always, I was impressed by TASA's ability to produce exceptionally well-qualified candidates with great speed."

    John Thomas Dzialo, The Law Offices of John Thomas Dzialo, Santa Ana, CA

  • Thank you for your quick response and the names of the two proposed experts. The situation that gave rise to our search for these experts has resolved and we will not need to retain them. However, we will continue to keep TASA in mind as these needs arise from time to time as your breadth of coverage for experts of all types is unparalleled, in my experience."

    Bart W. Brizzee, County of San Bernadino, San Bernadino, CA

  • I have used TASA for the last five years for locating an expert for many personal injury cases. On each and every occasion, TASA was able to find me more than one qualified expert. With such a variety of experts, I was able to select one who met my client's needs in prosecuting these claims. I found the experts TASA referred not only qualified, but available on a moment's notice. Your fees are reasonable and fair, and I will continue to use TASA for the remainder of my career."

    Robert Oushalem, Esq., The Law Office of Robert Oushalem, San Jose, CA

  • I recently used TASA for the first time to locate an expert to testify in a case requiring rather unusual expertise and where there were no applicable regulations or standards for guidance. TASA referred an expert in California who was everything a lawyer looks for in a forensic expert. He was promptly available for consultation, efficiently prepared for deposition and trial and very persuasive and credible with the jury. TASA's administrative services and assistance in locating this expert were excellent, and we would certainly use both the expert and TASA in the future."

    Theodore Phillips, Miller Hauser Law Group, LLP, Placerville, CA

  • TASA has always given me first-class service, but in a recent matter, TASA found the 'needle-in-the-haystack' expert witness we feared didn't exist. We needed an expert for a very narrow and limited issue in a very narrow and limited industry. Because TASA has an extensive expert witness database, it was able to give us a referral almost on the spot. It's why I always turn to TASA first."

    Kathleen A. Herdell, Law Offices of Kathleen A. Herdell, St. Helena, CA

  • There are numerous companies that provide litigation experts. However, I always choose the TASA Group because of their quick response in finding a qualified expert for my particular case. I have extreme confidence in the TASA Group and will continue to use their services in the future."

    Katie A. Killion, Esq., Chiurazzi & Mengine, LLC, Pittsburgh, PA

  • I spent hours trying to locate an expert in a very technical case involving a defect in a medical device. I could have saved a lot of time by calling TASA first. Within hours, I was supplied with the name of an engineer who had more than 30 years of job training, education and expertise in the precise area involving the device. Bravo TASA!"

    Timothy W. Peach, Partner, Peach & Weathers, San Bernardino, CA

  • We were involved in a case pending for more than five years with seven parties from three states. Three mediations failed before we looked to TASA for an expert. TASA referred an expert who clearly understood the complexity of the project and could effectively support his opinion. If it weren't for his expert advice and deposition testimony, the case would not have settled. Interestingly, the case settled within 90 days from the date this expert began."

    Renee Colbert, Esq., Corporate Counsel, W.G. Tomko, Inc., Finleyville, PA

  • Using TASA to find experts for defending our client in a negligent homicide case ended up being one of the most important decisions we made in trial preparation. The experts they suggested were exactly what we needed for the case. I truly did not expect to find experts that would be such a perfect fit for the nature of case. TASA provided us with highly qualified experts in somewhat narrow fields of expertise. A large percentage of our victory is due to the experts recommended by TASA."

    Marta Farmer, Esq., Carl S. White Law Office, Haver, MT

  • I have used TASA's services since the 1980's and have never been disappointed. TASA is indispensable for locating that hard-to-find expert. TASA representatives have always been courteous and pleasant, with the attitude that they cannot do enough to help. I expect to continue using TASA throughout my career."

    Brad W. Greenberg, Esq., Smyth Law Offices, P.C., Brockton, MA

  • I needed to retain a multitude of scientists from a variety of disciplines for a complex litigation. Initially, I went through a series of interviews with an extremely knowledgeable and professional team of TASA advisors. They were able to find highly qualified experts in the specific fields, all of whom turned out to be superior in qualification and area of expertise to my adversary’s experts. I am a TASA believer!"

    Nooshin Namazi, Partner, Nicoletti Hornig & Sweeney, New York, NY

  • TASA always comes through in the difficult IP cases. Their representatives work with you to refine the search criteria and quickly send you a list of very qualified experts."

    Timothy L. Boller, Principal, Seed Intellectual Property Law Group, PLLC, Seattle, WA

  • Special thanks to our TASA referral advisor for her quick response to our initial request—we were extremely happy with how fast TASA was able to assist us! Your group does excellent work, and it is always my first stop when looking for an expert."

    Susanne K. Sullivan, Senior Attorney, Southwest Airlines Corporation, Dallas, TX

  • When we needed an expert in a patent infringement lawsuit, we turned to TASA. We were looking for a witness qualified in two unrelated technical areas, and TASA worked with us to identify and refine our requirements. TASA performed well, promptly providing us with several excellent candidates to consider, one of whom we retained."

    Joseph T. Miotke, Partner, IP Practice Group, Michael Best & Friedrich LLP, Milwaukee, WI

  • Our team had a very positive experience with TASA. The Expert was professional, efficient, and certainly an expert in his field. His work and testimony contributed to a winning decision for our client! We will recommend the Expert and TASA whenever appropriate."

    Stephanie Sprague, Esq., CT

  • (The Expert) WAS A PERFECT FIT for my case: qualified, competent, easy to work with, attentive to detail, knowledgeable, smart, communicative, enthusiastic, resourceful—have I left anything out? I highly recommend TASA and would be happy to share my experience with anyone else. Thank you!"

    Michael Porrazzo, Esq., The Porrazzo Law Firm, Mission Viejo, CA

  • The expert was very thorough. TASA was quick to respond with an answer to my request. I have used TASA in the past under various other law firms and have been pleased. TASA continues to live up to expectations and then some."

    Anne Desormier-Cartwright, Esq., Jupiter, FL

  • Your organization found us an appropriate expert witness in less than one day. This was excellent service. The expert you found was excellent and a pleasure to work with."

    William A. Ehrlich, Esq., Allentown, PA

  • (The Expert)…accomplished exactly what we wanted. TASA was very prompt and efficient in locating him. All fees were reasonable."

    J. Michael Lehman, Esq., Bruce, Bruce, & Lehman, Wichita, KS

  • We needed an Internet expert right away to meet a deadline. One phone call to TASA, and in less than a day, TASA called back with a list of 8-10 experts who were exactly what I needed. The TASA expert I chose knew the business and mechanics of the Internet so well—he was a PhD and professor who had written a book on the subject—that he put the fear of truth in the defendant that caused him to settle. When I get the kind of service that I did from TASA, I stick with it and use it again and again."

    Philip Green, Attorney at Law, Green and Green, San Rafael and San Francisco, CA

  • Excellent—in a word. I just do not have the time to hunt for experts. (The Expert) was fantastic. Thank you for providing such a quality service."

    Francesca Carinci, Esq., Steubenville, OH

  • TASA stands for Tops At Serving Attorneys. It’s always rewarding working with TASA."

    Marshall A. Bernstein, Esq., Philadelphia, PA.

  • That was, however, one of the best and most interesting webinars I've seen in the last few years.  Thank you for hosting it and introducing me to such a knowledgeable and caring person." - Referencing the Medicolegal Consequences of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in Civilian and Military Populations webinar. 

    Lori Bauer Apodaca, The Law Office of Lori Bauer Apodaca, Los Lunas, NM 

  • I needed a dental malpractice expert to assist me in a complex negligence claim. The very able staff at TASA had no difficulty identifying a knowledgeable professional who rendered a reasonable opinion in support of the case, which aided our client in receiving a fair amount of compensation. I am grateful to TASA for its invaluable assistance!"

    John Hermina, Hermina Law Group, New York, Pennsylvania, Maryland & Washington, DC

  • For many years I have relied upon TASAmed to provide excellent medical malpractice experts. As a sole practitioner, I find it reassuring to know that a seasoned expert is just a call away. Usually, TASAmed has found just the right expert in a day or two. The support and guidance I receive from TASAmed is a vital part of my law practice, and I have come to expect both great service and high rewards from my TASA cases."

    Thomas J. Massey, The Thomas J. Massey Law Firm, Fallbrook, CA

  • The caliber of physicians that TASAmed has referred to us is superb. Prior referral groups used the same experts over and over again. With TASAmed I have access to experts all over the United States. I’m not limited to the same experts. The TASAmed staff is easy to work with and very professional, with an established track record. When I call for a medical expert, I’m called back the same day, and I often have an idea of what expert will be contacted before my first call is completed."

    Kari Alexander, Certified Legal Nurse Consultant, Texas

  • We hadn’t been able to find the medical expert we needed, and, frankly, I didn’t think we’d find one in that field. TASAmed was able to find us an expert with the exact expertise and medical experience we needed. Your referral advisor was very helpful and found our expert in one day."

    Kurt Osenbaugh, Partner, Alston & Bird, Los Angeles, CA

  • TASAmed’s service was prompt and efficient in connecting us with the right person. The expert was so cooperative and helpful. With how challenging it is to find a narrow area of medical expertise, it’s extra helpful to have your TASAmed pool to plug into instantaneously."

    Greg Roosevelt, Esq., Law Office of Greg Roosevelt, Edwardsville, IL

  • TASAmed has connected me to credible experts in four medical cases just this year. TASAmed and the referred experts respond quickly, the fees are reasonable, and the referrals are well tuned to the fields I request. Since the experts are already associated with TASAmed, they are comfortable having substantial conversations about the case, both before and after record review."

    Martin A. Cannon, Esq., Cannon Law Offices, Crescent, IA

  • I have used TASAmed a number of times and have always been happy with your give-and-take timeliness. Once I requested a medical expert in a particular field, but, after speaking with your referral advisor, we concluded that an expert in another field would be more effective. That same day, I spoke to two experts the advisor gave me, and I retained one."

    Mark A. Lope, Esq., Lope and Honlihan, Butler, PA

  • Very close to the time of trial, the TASAmed advisor quickly referred me to several experienced ER trauma physicians to review medical records and prepare me for cross-examination. After selecting my expert, I over-nighted records for review, and the doctor found valuable information for my client's defense. Thank you, TASAmed, for this timely, specific, valuable referral."

    Charles Morgan, Esq., Law Office of Charles L. Morgan, Jr., Charlotte, NC